Get the Support You Need

Learn from thousands of users who have made their way through our courses. Need help getting started? Watch this short video.

today's top discussions:

logo

Challenging Worry

Ashley -> Health Educator

2024-04-20 11:42 PM

Depression Community

logo

Hello

Linda Q

2024-04-11 5:06 AM

Anxiety Community

logo

Addiction

Ashley -> Health Educator

2024-04-08 3:54 PM

Managing Drinking Community

This Month’s Leaders:

Most Supportive

Browse through 411.749 posts in 47.054 threads.

160,526 Members

Please welcome our newest members: eggmegrolf, PearlCat19, mima, FrannyLou, AABBYGAIL RUTH

antidepressives and placebos


16 years ago 0 8760 logo logo logo logo logo logo logo logo logo logo 0
No problem wildcat. I think this is a very common misconception. Again, one study does not established fact. If the study and it's results can be repeated that there is more evidence that is probable that the theory has ground. Danielle, Bilingual Health Educator
16 years ago 0 3043 logo logo logo logo logo logo logo logo logo logo 0
thanks danielle... I have trouble with research people coming out and announcing their "news". They seem to live in a vaccumm bubble that suddenly bursts open and they are all chatty... while the rest of us deal with information from 4 or 5 bubbles... and not one the same as the other! Like the news on omega-3 fatty acids from fish sources... Of course they have their info to protect and their names to highlite... but for those who follow only one break-through at a time ... it sparks too much hope ... and in this case it might push those who are only beginning meds to completely give-up on the pharmaceuticals because they are not a quick fix. Also, it pushes the idea that too many doctors are prescribing too much meds... when there are too many people who want a miracle in a bottle (... I feel bad -probably a cold- and will wait 8 hours at an emergency room for something to make me better!!! sniffles, fever, acks, all viral your body takes care of this...) And there are too many who do not take meds properly -like my chouette who never finishes a presciption- and have to take more meds and on the stronger kind. Here in Quebec, Paul Arcand, made a film "Quebec sur Ordonance" and it sparked a whole debate on the roles of doctors and of responsible patients. So thanks danielle for the reminder that one study is one one point of view of a big issue.
16 years ago 0 8760 logo logo logo logo logo logo logo logo logo logo 0
Gabs, You've brought up some very valid sides to this issue. Lets try to also remember that studies have flaws and weaknesses just like anything else and one study is not the be all and end all. Danielle, Bilingual Health Educator
16 years ago 0 172 logo logo logo logo logo logo logo logo logo logo 0
The news thst antidepressants were not really that helpful that made headline news in the u.k worried the life out of many people. Thankfully at this time, i feel strong enough to stick my fingers up at the reports and know that without the help of the meds i possibly wouldnt be here right now. The fact that Doctors have been dishing the drugs out like sweets to some poor people that may have just been in a low mood rather than real depression is more likely the reason that for these people the meds havent worked. If you really have a chemical imbalance then I believe that the right medication can be beneficial. Getting the right one, however is hit and miss as we all know. The news made me cross actually, as what do they intend to replace the drugs with? certainly here, there is such a shortage of therapists and even my doctor is ignorant how beneficial C.B.T is. She actually admitted that I know more about it than she does. I hope no one has stopped their meds suddenly because of this news as coming off these meds that 'do nothing' the withdrawel effects are terrible.
16 years ago 0 1890 logo logo logo logo logo logo logo logo logo logo 0
I'd prefer the feeling of basic contentment, Dumpling, rather than the miasma of struggling for whatever "happiness" really means - Glad that you're out of your deep valley - Thank God for the Spring... I can turn off my over-the-chair full spectrum light for a few months...
16 years ago 0 12049 logo logo logo logo logo logo logo logo logo logo 0
dumpling, Thank you for sharing your experience with us, we can all learn from one another :) Josie, Health Educator
16 years ago 0 101 logo logo logo logo logo logo logo logo logo logo 0
After the report that said that antidepressants were only slightly better than placebos in the moderately depressed, CBC radio had an interview with the head of the mood disorder clinic in Hamilton, Ontario. He said 2 things that rang true with me. 1. That most people don't realize how much good antidepressants are doing until they stop taking them. 2. That they have found that in many cases with people who have stopped taking medications that same medication does not work when they go back on it. This is exactly what happened with me. Two years ago, in a time of extreme family and work-related stress, I finally took a low dose (75 mg) of effexor offered by my family doctor. I was amazed at the results. I felt "normal" for the first time in a long time. I continued to take it for a year to make sure that the cure was effective, after reading all I could about it, then continued for a few months longer to pass the spring equinox and avoid SAD. Then I slowly weaned with no ill effects. By September I was in a major suicidal depression. I went back on Effexor and even tried higher doses, but continued cycling through mild depression and suicidal depression. I tried this site and it helped a bit but the dips continued. I have just come out of a deep pit and to my amazement found my self happy last Thursday. Not deliriously jump up and win the lottery happy, but really happy, normal happy. I had kept taking the medication because i was afraid to stop. So maybe, when you go back on, it takes 6 months, rather than 6 weeks to work. Hang in there. Work towards content.

Reading this thread: